Lastest News Icon

Latest News

Lastest News

TO’s and FRO’s of ownership of the freehold of a small block of residential flats Company -v- Individuals in collective acquisition or freehold purchase in pursuance of a right of first refusal

As with everything there are benefits either way.  With only two flats it is really difficult to assess whether one outweighs the benefit of the other.

Company:

The real benefit of holding as a company is that it is easier on sale or purchase of the flats as it simply necessitate that the outgoing party signs a stock transfer form to transfer the share in the company and thus there is no real input from the other party but when held by individuals it means that that when a flat is sold or transferred it need both leaseholders to be a party to the transfer of the interest in the freehold.  That is fine provided that both remain “friendly” and both are “around”.

Individuals:

Avoids  the need for compliance with filing at Company House and the individuals can be “controlled” pursuant to a Trust Deed.  On sale or transfer the new owner would be compelled to signing up to the trust deed.

Other points to consider:

  1. Limited Liability
  • In a company: The company’s liability is limited to its assets, which means the directors and shareholders are not personally liable for any debts or claims made against the company. If something goes wrong, such as legal action, the directors’ personal finances are typically protected.
  • In individual names: If the freehold is held by individuals, they would be personally liable for any legal or financial issues, such as maintenance disputes or debts.
  1. Taxes where relevant
  • In a company: Companies can benefit from certain tax advantages. For example, they may be able to deduct certain expenses related to the management of the property, like maintenance or legal fees, which could reduce the overall tax liability.
  • In individual names: The rental income or capital gains may be taxed at the individual’s income tax rate, which could be higher than the corporate tax rate, especially for higher earners.
  1. Smoother Ownership Transition as above
  • In a company: Shares/membership  in the company can be transferred more easily, allowing for a smoother transition of ownership when a leaseholder sells or passes on their shareholding. This can avoid complications around transferring the actual freehold or needing approval for each individual change of ownership.
  • In individual names: Transferring the freehold might involve more paperwork or complications if ownership needs to change, especially if one of the leaseholders decides to sell or leave.
  1. Control and Management
  • In a company: With the leaseholders being directors and shareholders of the company, they have control over decisions affecting the management of the building, including maintenance, rent reviews, and other important aspects. This system helps in giving leaseholders a collective say, and there’s a more formal structure for decision-making.
  • In individual names: The management could be less structured, with individual owners potentially having differing interests or control, making decision-making more difficult or causing conflicts.  Saying that we would attempt to ensure that the Trust Deed sets down obligations to control input into management.
  1. Management and Decision-Making
  • In a company: With leaseholders as directors, everyone has a direct interest in the building’s maintenance and management, encouraging a more cohesive and collaborative approach to decisions. The directors have a responsibility to act in the best interests of the company (i.e., all the leaseholders).
  • In individual names: The decisions might be more fragmented as each individual can act independently, and disagreements could arise about the future of the building or its maintenance. Usually this should not occur but if one flat is sold to a “difficult” leaseholder then you may see instances of this.
  1. Memorandum and Articles of Association
  • In a company: Companies and their powers are governed by articles of association, which create a formal framework for decision-making and the resolution of disputes. This structure provides a clear process for managing issues related to the freehold.  The Memorandum and Articles of Association of a company are its bible. They set down the powers of the company what it can and cannot do and provisions for making decisions.  A Company cannot act outside those powers and a single director cannot act individually unless the articles state so.
  • In individual names: Without a formal governance structure, resolving conflicts may be more difficult but again I would address this in a Trust Deed.

 

Adcocks Solicitors Limited’s Enfranchisement and Residential Leasehold Team specialise in Collective Enfranchisement and Freehold Acquisitions Contact Linda:  LB@adcocks.com

<< Back to latest news